Have you ever made a purchasing decision based on one of these food label claims?
More fiber than [fill in the blank] !
With [fill in the blank] grams of fiber!
You may have been played by a clever food marketer.
What exactly is fiber? Fiber used to be defined as “roughage”, stuff that didn’t get digested, like those stringy bits in celery or the bran in whole wheat or corn kernels. But the official official FDA definition of fiber includes all kinds of things that have no relationship to roughage:
“non-digestible soluble and insoluble carbohydrates (with 3 or more monomeric units), and lignin that are intrinsic and intact in plants; isolated or synthetic non-digestible carbohydrates (with 3 or more monomeric units) determined by FDA to have physiological effects that are beneficial to human health.”
No strings or roughage anywhere to be found. Instead we get monomeric units, gums, gels and short-chain carbohydrates that are fermented by bacteria. In short, anything that isn’t digested or absorbed by a human. This definition gives the food industry incentive to identify non-digested/non-absorbed stuff that can be added to manufactured foods to boost the fiber content, including foods that never, ever had fiber in their natural state, such as yogurt. Yogurt with added celery strings might be higher in fiber, but who would buy that? But you can officially make your yogurt “high fiber” by adding inulin — a non-digestible carbohydrate that dissolves in liquid. You can slap a High Fiber Health Halo on the yogurt and gain market advantage. You can also add inulin or wheat dextrin to the mix for leaden energy bars or extruded cereals and make a high fiber claim on the label.
Why do we want more fiber?
Fiber has a great reputation. It’s supposed to keep you regular, lower cholesterol, control blood sugar and make you feel full so you eat less, perhaps aiding weight loss efforts. These’s some truth to those claims for some types of fiber, but not to all types of fiber. Food marketers would prefer that consumers remain in the dark about those differences, and just believe that all fibers provide all benefits. Precisely the kind of nutrition fakery I detest. And I’m not alone. I ran across an article recently that backed up my annoyance with specifics about what different fibers do and do not do. It turns out, the best fibers for health benefits are the ones from whole foods. No surprise there.
The article is chock full of details about how different fiber types are handled in the digestive tract. Check out the article if you want the extreme details, such as the importance of viscosity, the gel-forming properties of carbohydrate chains and the fermentation of extracted fiber additives. If you don’t have the time to wade through that, here are some of the key points:
- There are two basic classes of “fiber”: soluble and insoluble, which refers to chemical properties of the fiber.
- Soluble fibers from intact foods (such as from oats or psyllium) hold water and are effective for lowering cholesterol or controlling blood sugar, thanks to their molecular structure. Because these fibers are effective at holding on to water, they are effective stool softeners.
- Insoluble fibers, such as from wheat bran, do not impact cholesterol or blood sugar. They can have a laxative effect due to direct irritation of the gut mucosa, which leads to secretion of mucous and water, promoting laxation.
- Research does not show any of these benefits from the extracted non-digestible fibers, like inulin or wheat dextrin, that are added to manufactured foods to create a health halo. I actually was not completely aware of this, so I found the article fascinating, and increasingly infuriating. Consumers are being lured into buying products that may not be all that helpful. It doesn’t help that these fiber additives are officially in the soluble fiber category, so someone who knows a little about fiber might end up concluding that the inulin in their mint chocolate energy bar is going to do them some good. Sad.
There was one other interesting piece of information not related to those extracted fiber ingredients. People with irritable bowel or diarrhea may think increasing fiber is a bad idea, but they might be half mistaken. Insoluble fibers like wheat bran, that work by irritating the gut mucosa, would not be a great choice if your gut mucosa is already irritated. But soluble fiber like psyllium or oats, which bind and hold water, have been shown to normalize stool for people with diarrhea.
So where do you get fiber if not from your yogurt or from an inulin-ized energy bar or a fiber supplement tablet (just…. No!) ? From whole plant foods. Some top sources of soluble fiber include:
- oranges, apples, pears, apricots
- psyllium seed and ground flax seed
For insoluble fiber, whole grains are best, as well as the peels on fruits and some vegetables. In general, eat a plant-based diet with plenty of fruits and vegetables, legumes and nuts. You won’t have to worry about getting so many grams of insoluble or soluble fiber. You just get lots of fiber from a variety of sources. You know, the way Mother Nature intended it.